

I have been honest about Constitution Hill for nearly two years, and I am going to be honest again: it is time for owner Michael Buckley and trainer Nicky Henderson to have a serious conversation about Constitution Hill retirement. Many punters still treat him as a champion. However, my view, and it is an opinion, is that Constitution Hill is somewhat overrated on the evidence of his last 20 months. Backing him has become a losing game. I took plenty of stick for saying so when it was unpopular. Here is the case, with the facts laid out so you can judge for yourself.
This is an opinion piece. I have huge respect for Nicky Henderson’s record and for Michael Buckley’s commitment to the horse. Importantly, I have included their side of the argument below. The question of whether Constitution Hill has proved overrated is one that people will debate, but it is central to my analysis.
After his 2024 Christmas Hurdle at Kempton, where he beat Lossiemouth by 2.5 lengths, I was vocal that he was the lay of the century. Lossiemouth did not look herself that day. For me, the performance did not match the price. A month later he made a mistake at the last in the International Hurdle at Cheltenham, beating Brentford Boy at 1/12. That was exactly the sort of warning sign I was looking at before the Champion Hurdle.

Then came the run of results that followed:
That is three falls in four hurdle starts. Connections switched him to the Flat, which was a sensible attempt to find a new path for him. Watching these results over time, even fans must wonder whether Constitution Hill is overrated as a performer now.
It started well. He won at Southwell in February and again at Kempton in March. Since then the picture has changed:
Henderson said afterwards that the horse bounced well, got shuffled back and that his career is not all over by a very long way. I respect that. But the results do not support the optimism. The impression is increasingly one of Constitution Hill overrated when faced with tougher competition; a nine-year-old being asked to compete in Group 2 company against younger horses is a very different task from the one he mastered over hurdles.
It is only fair to put their position across, because they have been clear about it. After Milan, Michael Buckley told critics to wind their necks in. He said the horse looked magnificent, happy and relaxed, that Henderson is careful and does not over-race his horses, and that if the horse showed any signs he had had enough, they would probably retire him. Furthermore, they are also clear that the horse enjoys his travels and that the plan is to keep going.
I do not doubt their sincerity. Nobody knows this horse better than the people who see him every day, and they have earned the right to make the decision. But a punter does not have to agree with the optimism. From my point of view, Constitution Hill overrated compared to the media hype, at least in recent seasons.
This is the part that matters most to me. A horse who has fallen repeatedly over hurdles and has now been beaten on the Flat is a horse whose connections should be thinking hard about his future. Importantly, retirement is not a failure. For a horse who has won a Champion Hurdle, an Aintree Hurdle and three Christmas Hurdles, it would be a deserved reward.
Racing’s reputation depends on how horses are treated when their best days are behind them. A champion running down the field in Group races is not the image the sport wants. I would rather see him leave the stage with his reputation intact than keep taking on tasks that look beyond him. On the welfare side, Constitution Hill overrated by expectations may also be facing a crossroads that connections cannot ignore.
Whatever you think about when he should retire, there is a betting lesson here that applies far beyond one horse:
It genuinely saddens me to see people lose money backing a horse on reputation alone. I would never claim that any horse is certain to lose, and I may be proved wrong. But I would rather be honest than popular. Still, it’s a reminder that sometimes horses, even legends, turn out overrated—Constitution Hill’s story is the evidence punters should learn from.
Constitution Hill gave us some of the most thrilling hurdling of the last decade, and nothing in this article takes that away. But the facts of the last 20 months point one way. Therefore, I believe the kind thing to do for the horse, and for the punters who love him, is for Michael Buckley and Nicky Henderson to think seriously about Constitution Hill’s retirement while his reputation is still golden. Until then, be wary of the name, especially if you believe Constitution Hill to be overrated, and trust the evidence.
At Premium Racing Tips, we do not bet on reputations. We bet on value, backed by form, market analysis and discipline. Over 1,500 points profit. 40 out of 48 months in the green. More than 1,000 members receiving professional daily selections via Telegram.
Join Premium Racing Tips today and get selections built on evidence rather than headlines, delivered straight to your phone.